Showing posts with label Pittsburgh. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pittsburgh. Show all posts

19 November 2025

Self-Defense Is Legal in Pennsylvania

DAs HATE that. Jury acquits man in Banksville Road killing | Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

A jury on Friday acquitted a Beechview man in the death of another man, finding that Connor Makstutis acted in self-defense when he shot Richard Derkach on Banksville Road in 2023.

A years-long campaign of harassment, that included shots fired at the defendant's home. It ended in traffic.

Mr. Makstutis testified that by the time he ended up trapped in rush hour traffic with Mr. Derkach at his car window, he felt like “it was him or me.”

Banksville is a neighborhood in Pittsburgh.

The DA wanted to win, and didn't care about all of that, but it didn't turn out the way the DA wanted.

Assistant District Attorney Matthew Newman had told the jury that Mr. Derkach was unarmed and that Mr. Makstutis had no reason to open fire.

Did he know that? Is the DA saying you can't beat someone to death? Are you supposed to submit to beatings if the other guy is "isn't armed?" How do you know if he is armed or not?

Closing arguments were in the morning. The jury was done by 2PM the same day. I would say they didn't buy what the DA was trying to sell.

14 July 2024

Neglect of Maintenance and a Bridge Collapse

On 28 January 2022 at 6:37 a.m. the Fern Hollow Bridge in Pittsburgh collapsed. No one died, but several people were severely injured. It isn't fair to say that it collapsed without warning, because many years of bridge inspection reports described what was wrong, how it was getting worse, and what should have been done to fix it. Nothing was done.

Neglect? Maybe that should be criminal negligence. Though I doubt anyone who decided that "we have more important stuff to spend money on this year," like parades, and virtue signalling, will be held accountable in this life.

From 2005 onward, recommendations from inspection reports to repair parts of the bridge, didn't fall off the list, they just kept being repeated by each new inspection, year after year. Pittsburgh just didn't fix it.

17 years is a long time to ignore failing infrastructure. Every inspection report starting in 2007 specified the critical structural members of the bridge that were being corroded, and need to be repaired. The reports also called out drainage problems - clogged drain gates. These were also ignored, which accelerated the problems.

This is a good report on the collapse from Practical Engineering. This Bridge Should Have Been Closed Years Before It Collapsed.

Maintaining infrastructure is thankless work. Don’t get me wrong, it can be a really rewarding career. Inspections involve a lot of time out in the field seeing cool structures up close. And repair projects are often interesting challenges for contractors. But they’re not rewarding in the same way that designing and building new stuff can be. No one holds a press conference and cuts a big ribbon at the end of a bridge inspection or structural retrofit. Building a new structure is not just an achievement in its own right; it’s a commitment to take good care of it for its entire design life, and then to rehabilitate, or replace, or even close it when it’s no longer safe for the public.

This is the Practical Engineering video This Bridge Should Have Been Closed Years Before It Collapsed

The NTSB report on the collapse can be found at the following link. Collapse of the Fern Hollow Bridge.

The report includes 3 videos. The 2nd video in the list, is partly an animation of the collapse of the bridge as recreated by the engineering forensics team. If you're interested in such things, it is only 8 minutes. It includes photos of the rusted portions of the bridge from prior years inspection reports.

Rust Never Sleeps is also the name of an album.

16 April 2024

Is Pittsburgh Losing Law and Order Completely?

From Massad Ayoob: IS PITTSBURGH THE CANARY IN THE MINESHAFT?

Pittsburgh is now getting an extra-strong taste of what’s happening around the country. Anti-police politicians, prosecutors, and media outlets have told young people who would have been good cops that they don’t want to become the Gestapo, and veteran cops are leaving the profession in droves.

There are never enough police to be everywhere at once. "When seconds count, police are only minutes away." But when there are no police, and prosecutors stop prosecuting, when there is no jail for crimes like shoplifting, and all the rest, then society will break down.

Stores can't give away $1000 to everyone who walks through the door and stay in business. If stores (and restaurants and bars) close, people will not live in the city. Crowding and crime were offset in the past by nightlife, convenience, and a cool factor. But if you add to the crime, and subtract everything else why will people with a choice stay in your city?

I know I say it too much, but society is built on security, and the idea that security is required for civilization to endure is not new. Hobbes published Leviathan in 1651. In that book he describes the State of War that ensues when law and order break down. Well, law and order are breaking down in some of the cities, probably with more to come.

15 March 2024

Pittsburgh Police Cut 911 Response Criteria

Staffing shortages lead to 911 response problems. Pittsburgh Police Cuts Cops During Hours Of 3 a.m.-7 a.m.

The first change, is if it is not an "in progress emergency" police will not respond. If if happened 10 minutes ago. They will not respond. Instead people will be expected to file a report over the phone. If you call 911 they will transfer you to the appropriate people.

And the hours from 3 a.m. to 7 a.m. you won't even be able to do that, you will have to call back.

Chief Scirotto says that the majority of major 911 calls, referred to as "priority calls" by the bureau, occur between 2 p.m. and 2 a.m., while significantly fewer calls are received during the 3 a.m. to 7 a.m. timeframe.

This prompted Chief Scirotto to reevaluate the allocation of resources during these overnight hours in order to address the ongoing shortage of officers and optimize their deployment.

It all comes down to the question, "What can they do?" They can't do everything.

I think it would be better if they just came out said, "You are on your own. We will be there when we can, but odds are, we won't be there when you need us." Of course they won't say that.

“They’re running out of manpower very, very quickly, and they’re getting very taxed. I think the strategy at this point is a hope and a prayer that they can base everyone on data,” Swartzwelder told the PG. “It may pan out to be correct. It may be disastrous.”

I found out about this by way of Colion Noir's video Pittsburgh Police Will Only Respond To Emergencies & No Officers in Dispatch Offices 3-7 am Daily. It is 9 minute video and worth your time.

06 January 2024

"It's Over" is a Sentence People Need to Understand

What exactly does the gun-hating part of the Left think this woman should have done? Man shot by ex-girlfriend while breaking into her Pittsburgh home

He clearly was not stopping by to reminisce over the good old days. He was also in violation of a Protection from Abuse order.

You should click thru for the details.

After he was shot, he took himself to the hospital. He is facing charges that include criminal trespass, stalking and burglary.

So again, what do the anti-gun folks think she should have done? She got an order of protection. She called 911. 911 told her to shoot the bastard. They say that the police will protect you. But the police were nowhere near when this incident took place, and they have no duty to protect you, not even if you have a court order.

Self-defense is a human-right, and I think it will be hard to charge the woman for defending herself. That doesn't mean a determined leftist DA couldn't charge her, but they would look like a fool if they did.

14 December 2023

A Tool to Defend Yourself

Salena Zito: For many, owning a gun was taboo. Now they’re buying them.

This follows, for the most part, one man's journey from anti-gun to gun owner.

The first time David picked up a gun to learn how to use it — this time for protection — was five years ago, when he went to a range a few weeks after Robert Bowers walked into the Tree of Life synagogue and killed 11 people who had gathered to worship not far from David’s home in the Squirrel Hill neighborhood of Pittsburgh.

He took a class, and considered buying a firearm, but he didn't. Then October 2023 rolled around.

Then Oct. 7 happened — and everything else that went with it in the following days and weeks, like the brazen antisemitic graffiti splattered on the front wall of Allderdice High School and throughout the Summerset neighborhood, as well as the tire slashings, the defacing and burning of lawn signs that support Israel, and the woman using a hammer to hit the window of Marvista Design where a sign read “We Stand With Israel.”

Antisemitism has skyrocketed since 7 October.

Last month, the Anti-Defamation League reported antisemitic incidents in the United States rose by about 400% in the first two weeks alone after the war broke out. By the end of October, that number hit an average of 28 a day — and is still climbing.

And people who previously didn't think about owning a firearm, now realize that they might need to protect themselves.

That was reflected in background checks for firearms in October.

The National Shooting Sports Foundation reports over 1.3 million gun checks, an 8.3% increase over the same period in 2022.

There is more. A gun instructor who is running classes in the community, and even taught one free class as an act of giving back. And the quote from the movie Shane that gave rise to the title to this post.

Instead, [Shane] says it’s “a tool, like a shovel or a hammer or an axe. It’s not bad in and of itself; it’s what you do with it.”

There is also an interesting discussion how firearms weren't always a Republican thing. Do you think autoworkers in Ohio or Michigan might have gone hunting in the fall? Click thru. (Hat tip to Slow Facts)

19 April 2022

The Mass Shooting That Will Disappear From the News

Because actually holding criminals to account for their actions would be bad. Mass shooting in Pittsburgh leaves 11 injured, 2 dead.

An "underage drinking party." There should be a law! Oh, wait... There were 200 people at that party.

Will AirBnB ever be held accountable for the insanity they cause? Probably not.

The gunfire unfolded at an AirBnB property being rented on Madison Avenue shortly after 1 a.m. on Sunday. Authorities estimate as many as 200 people were at the house.

About 50 rounds were fired inside the home forcing partygoers to jump out of windows and suffer broken bones and lacerations.

Hat tip to William Teach (via Twitter).

The Pittsburgh area shooting will be minimized, because it doesn't fit the Narrative

One story said that Shot Spotter counted "more than 90" shots fired. At an underage party.

I'm guessing something like high-school seniors, that kind of underage.