27 December 2025

The Great Promise of AI? Not Hardly

In Big Tech's rush to add AI to everything, they are breaking a lot of things. From The Verge, we get an update on Smart Homes. How AI broke the smart home in 2025: The arrival of generative AI assistants in our smart homes held such promise; instead, they struggle to turn on the lights.

This morning, I asked my Alexa-enabled Bosch coffee machine to make me a coffee. Instead of running my routine, it told me it couldn’t do that. Ever since I upgraded to Alexa Plus, Amazon’s generative-AI-powered voice assistant, it has failed to reliably run my coffee routine, coming up with a different excuse almost every time I ask.

It’s 2025, and AI still can’t reliably control my smart home. I’m beginning to wonder if it ever will.

The promise of AI in the Smart Home, was that it was going to make it easier to set things up, and easier for people to get things done, like run that "Make the coffee" routine. It hasn't worked out that way.

Click thru for the details of how Amazon made things worse with AI. The old systems were dependent on you using precise vocabulary, but it could actually do things.

Hat tip to Pixy Misa at Ambient Irony and Daily News Stuff 24 December 2025: Zero Shopping Days Edition

How AI broke the smart home in 2025. (The Verge) (archive site)

When all you have is an LLM, everything looks like a chat room.

Contrary to what they seem to believe in C-suites across corporate America, AI is not the answer to everything.

You know what this reminds me of?

Tech Enthusiasts: Everything in my house is wired to the Internet of Things! I control it all from my smartphone! My smart-house is Bluetooth enabled and I can give it voice commands via Alexa! I love the future!

Programmers / Engineers: The most recent piece of technology I own is a printer from 2004 and I keep a loaded gun ready to shoot it if it ever makes an unexpected noise.

Ice Queen

Today's song was released on Friday 19 December as part of the celebration of 25 years of their breakthrough album. Mother Earth wasn't Within Temptation's first album, but it was the one that got them attention. Not in the US of course. The tiny minds that run the music industry in the US can't wrap their minds around Symphonic Metal, even when the singers are singing in English.

This is the 2025 acoustic version of "Ice Queen" by Within Temptation. It was originally on the 2000 album Mother Earth.

26 December 2025

Friday Links - 26 December

William Teach at Pirate's Cove starts us off with Sob: American Immigration Law Costing Illegals Over The Holidays

She could have gone with, right? Oh, wait, Mexico has some seriously strict immigration laws.

Lone Star Parson - Are We At Peak Skulduggery?

Did you know, dear friends, that the UK has a Brigadier General, yes, a Brigadier, admittedly retired, entirely devoted to Climate Change? You didn't? Now you do.

MaddMedic at Freedom Is Just Another Word… - CCP Conducts Mass Arrests of Christians Days before Christmas

Won’t hear about this from our biASSed, leftist media!!

Beege Welborn at HotAir - Newsom Loses More CA Business and Wants to Take Away the Farm

But until I read Katie's post, I did not know that Newsom and his toadies in Sacramento were going after farms as a means of reparations. What they are contemplating legislating is so blatantly an unconstitutional land grab that the Secretary of Agriculture, Brooke Rollins, is now involved.

Nick Arama at RedState - Cue the Meltdowns: Bari Weiss Dropping the Hammer With Big Changes After '60 Minutes' Story Fiasco

Sounds like Weiss is going to make changes that will be better for journalism at the network, whether they like it or not. Cue the meltdowns; you know they will be coming.

Again from MaddMedic at Freedom Is Just Another Word… - Poor Timmy…

A sitting Democrat governor effectively labeled millions of ordinary Americans, working families, veterans, parents, and taxpayers, as “extremists” simply because they reject the Left’s obsession with collective racial guilt.

Middle of the Right - Wow….

Hard to believe:

Primerica Investments sent me a Real, Honest to God, Christmas card.

The Other McCain - Make Nakatomi Plaza Great Again

Hard to believe it’s been 37 years since NYPD Detective John McClane saved his estranged wife Holly from the evil terrorist Hans Gruber, a saga memorialized in the classic documentary Die Hard, which all good patriotic Americans know is the best Christmas movie ever.

AmmoLand - New Zealand to Reform Draconian Firearms Law

The Hon Nicole McKee is an impressive woman. She appears to be doing the best she can with the situation as it exists. With only five percent of the population as legal gun owners and no Second Amendment, she is pushing for the rule of law when it comes to firearm ownership in New Zealand.

Don Surber - When CBS silenced Andy Rooney. Twice.

Rooney walked when CBS spiked his essay on war. It was an opinion piece that he wouldn’t change.

I suggest that if Alfonsi meant her story as an opinion piece, she should walk, too.

Pixy Misa at Ambient Irony - Daily News Stuff 24 December 2025: Zero Shopping Days Edition

Former Samsung executives and employees have been hit with criminal charges for leaking trade secrets on memory production to Chinese memory manufacturer CXMT. (WCCFTech)

Cool. I mean, tut tut, don't do that again.

Good Guys 2, Bad Guys 0

I would like the gun-hating part of the Left to explain to me how this would be better if the homeowner didn't have the legal means to defend himself. Homeowner shoots armed men who approached garage, police say

An investigation is underway in the west valley after a homeowner shot two armed men who approached him in his garage, according to Metro Police.

Both of the would-be, bad guys are in the hospital in stable condition. No word on any charges, though I don't expect the homeowner to be charged for defending himself in Las Vegas.

Electric School Buses are NOT Being Heated in New York

I love it when politicians pretend they are engineers. Energy requirements for heat? I'm sure that won't be an issue. Parents raise concerns over heat issues in electric school buses in Lake Shore Central School District

On the heels of a statewide mandate requiring all school bus purchases in New York State be electric by 2027, parents in the Lake Shore Central School District are speaking out, claiming some bus drivers are turning the heat down, or off completely, in an attempt to conserve battery life on their electric school buses.

The powers-that-be are assuring you that the buses meet the heating standards. The kids are telling a different story.

“They’re living in New York City, which is also La La Land, because this is a city-centric mandate,” Sen. Weik said in response to the NYSERDA’s assertions. “This might work in New York City where the bus routes might be a mile to a quarter of a mile long, and gas stations are hard to come by in a city that’s so overcrowded and developed, but that’s not the case for the rest of New York whether you’re on Long Island or Upstate.”

This is the MGUY Australia video Heaters in ELECTRIC school buses TURNED OFF to SAVE BATTERY

Every single electron you take out of that traction battery and which is not converted to motion of the vehicle will inevitably reduce the usable range of a full charge. But none of this seemed to concern the state of New York, which mandated that all school buses must be electric, despite the fact that it can get very cold in winter.

The video is just under 7 minutes.

$9 Billion (or More) Fraud in Minnesota Government Programs

Is anyone shocked? US Attorney's Office: 'Half or more' of $18B billed through state programs tied to fraud - KSTP 5 Eyewitness News

As the U.S. Attorney’s Office announced a new batch of charges related to suspected fraudulent billing in Minnesota’s government services, officials painted a dire portrait of just how extensive the problem might be.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Joe Thompson on Thursday said the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) pulled claims for 14 programs identified by Minnesota officials as being particularly vulnerable to fraud and found $18 billion in Medicaid billing since 2018.

While not all of those payments were illegitimate, Thompson estimated “half or more” of the $18 billion was received through fraudulent means, though he said prosecutors are still working to find the exact number.

I would love to say that this was because it is a Blue State, but all government is up to no good. Minnesota is just a particularly bad example.

I really don't expect much to come from this, unless the people of Minnesota wake up and take control of their government, and they seem to be more focused on Orange Man Bad than how their tax dollars are spent.

Hat tip to Ace at Ace of Spades HQ: Feds Discover Another $9 Billion in Medicaid Fraud... All in Tim Walz's Pirate Paradise of Minnesota

25 December 2025

Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays, Or Whatever

I hope everyone has a great day. (Scroll down for a Musical Interlude.)

This is "Veni, veni Emmanuel" by the King's Singers. It was recorded in January 2011 at St. Lukes London, England. The King's Singers are a British a cappella vocal group. They are named for King's College in Cambridge.

An Important Lesson About Having a Firearm

Possessing a firearm doesn't make you the most dangerous person in the room. Attitude counts for a lot. Man, 35, Dies After Shot By Own Gun In Struggle With Homeowner During Attempted Break-In: Police | Manhattan, IL Patch

According to the statement, police say Hayes and an accomplice attempted to forcibly enter the apartment, and Hayes was reportedly armed with a shotgun.

A physical struggle ensued between Hayes and the resident, during which the resident discharged the shotgun, striking Hayes, police said.

While I wouldn't want to face a shotgun with just my bare hands, if it was a question of "him or me" I would fight to make sure it was him.

No word on the other guy, who was with Hayes, so I assume that he ran.

There is also no word on what the motive might have been. Was it a simple break-in, or was it personal?

Self-defense is a human right. It may or may not be your legal right in Illinois.

Manhattan, Illinois is a small village in Will County. It is about 10 miles southeast of Joliet, or about a 50 mile drive southwest of downtown Chicago. I don't have a feeling for how the current Criminal Justice System in Will County views self-defense, but I would guess that they support it.

Media Bias? What Media Bias?

The Other McCain has a story of Media Bias. Journalism, Credibility and ‘Experts’

Robert Stacy McCain highlights the fact that the NPR Standards Chief has issued a directive that NPR "Journalists" stop quoting Carl Tobias. Tobias is a professor of law from The University of Richmond. He has been quoted 77 times on a "variety of topics."

That 77 times was on NPR. He is also quoted in other "news outlets."

At risk of going off on a tangent, permit me to note a relevant fact: University of Tennessee Law Professor Glenn Reynolds has opinions on all kinds of subjects, but you never see him quoted as an “expert” by NPR, the New York Times, Associated Press, etc. Why do you think that is?

Professor Reynolds is not a partisan Democrat, that’s why. These journalists quoting Professor Tobias are partisan Democrats, and his dial-a-quote service flourished because so-called “mainstream” journalism has become nothing but Democratic Party propaganda.

Click thru for details, and more on the liberal media's fall from credibility.

The Force Awakens Tenth Anniversary

The premiere was on 14 December, with the general release on 18 December 2015. The 10 year anniversary seems like a time to reconsider what it did to our beloved Star Wars. Not that Disney-Lucasfilm is remembering. But Nerdrotic is.

This date doesn't mark what most consider the death of Disney-Lucasfilm, but it is a prominent date in the death of the Star Wars saga.

Personally, I hate the prequel trilogy. I didn't pay to see all of them in the theater.

I didn't watch The Force Awakens in the theater, and I haven't seen all of it, giving up partway through. I don't think I've seen any of The Last Jedi and I've only seen clips of The Rise of Skywalker Palpatine. Well, I've probably seen clips of The Last Jedi without realizing which movie they are from.

I like the original trilogy. It was a fun set of movies that told a fairly standard hero's story. The prequels were about a trade dispute, and politics. The sequel trilogy was about a Mary Sue, who could do no wrong, and was perfect at everything. Neither of those 2 things make for great storytelling.

Anyway, Gary at Nerdrotic has watched (or re-watched) this movie so I don't have to.

This is the Nerdrotic video The Force Awakens - How Disney Destroyed Star Wars

A film becomes a classic through a rare blend of timeless storytelling, artistic innovation, deep emotional resonance, and lasting cultural significance, allowing it to endure beyond fleeting trends by connecting it with audiences across generations through memorable characters, profound themes, and cinematic milestones that influence film making itself, creating a shared experience that stands the test of time. And that's everything Disney's Star Wars Episode 7, The Force Awakens isn't.

The video is nearly an hour, so plan accordingly.

Film Threat held a funeral for the franchise last year. It is on YouTube, and individual sections are on YT in manageable time chunks. Film Threat also put Disney-Lucasfilm on trail for crimes against the art. Both are easy enough to find if you are interested. Chris Gore was apparently a huge Star Wars fan in his youth.

The death of Lucasfilm can probably be tied to the day George L. sold to Bob Iger and Co. If you don't like that date, the release of The Rise of Skywalker Palpatine is probably a good date. Most people checked out after that. Some fans held on until The Acolyte was released. I'm not sure why that was a step too far, but the fire in the vacuum of space, the runaway fire in the 100% stone installation, and Lesbian Space Witches probably contributed to the demise.

24 December 2025

Wednesday Link Roundup - Christmas Eve Edition

William Teach of Pirate's Cove starts us off with Sorta Blogless Sunday Pinup

Don Surber has highlights of the week.
Doug Ross has Larwyn’s Linx. And more Larwyn’s Linx.

EBL - MAGA Clinton Epstein Files ☀️

Bill Clinton in the Epstein files
Instapundit: Bill Clinton frolicking in the pool...

Wombat-socho - In The Mailbox: 12.22.25

Transterrestrial Musings: The Dark Ages
Victory Girls: Walz And Lapdog MN Media Cover Up $9 Billion Somali Fraud

Pixy Misa at Ambient Irony - Daily News Stuff 20 December 2025: Warp Speed Edition

LG is allowing customers to delete the Microsoft Copilot app it forced onto their televisions. (Tom's Hardware)
Or will do at some point.

A View from the Beach - Flotsam and Jetsam - Trump Plays Battleship

Ace woke up and noticed Epstein Files Reveal Bill Clinton Cavorting With Very Young Women on Pedo Island; Democrat Flacks and Leftwing Media -- But I Repeat Myself-- Claim Trump Is "Curating" the Photos to Make Slick Willy Look Bad, "Plus a rousing chorus of "But Trump!!!""

Bacon Time!!!! - Sunday Linkange

The Midwest Chick Saturday Meme Drop………….
Pirates Cove Extinction Rebellion Goes Dark For Their Protest

Vlad Tepes - Religious war is for all the marbles: Links 1 for December 23rd, 2025

This is the joint effort by communists and Muslims/Islam to take down Western civilization to the very roots. What will replace it will be so much worse it can’t even be described. Think of Saudi Arabia with all the public beheadings and no oil money.

Political Hat - News of the Week (December 21st, 2025)

New York’s Death Wish: Abandoning the Most Vulnerable to Assisted Suicide It’s not surprising, but it is shocking and devastating all the same. Empire State Governor Kathy Hochul is about to sign the assisted-suicide bill.

Gates of Vienna - News Feed 12/20/2025

Gas Prices Drop to Lowest December Levels Since 2020
Gasoline prices are expected to fall further this holiday season, giving travelers relief at the pump as national averages dip below 2020 levels.

Small Dead Animals - Monday On Turtle Island

Conman Carney’s Canada: Hamas in Chowtown. Censoring Rebel News. Canadians voted for this.
The Democratic Party’s America: L.A. legalizes assaulting ICE agents. The Story of America.

Don Surber - HIGHLIGHTS OF THE WEEK

ITEM 11: Breitbart reported, “All net job growth is going to native-born Americans as foreign-born employment continues to decline, a new jobs report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics issued on Tuesday reveals.”

The Glibertarians - Tuesday Morning Links

Trump DOJ Sues D.C. For Banning ‘Most Popular Firearms’
DHS Raises Self-Deport Bonus to $3K

Cafe Hayek - Some Links

Peter Earle is correct: “Eye-catching statistics about executive compensation tell us nothing about fairness, and distract from the real drivers of wage growth and worker prosperity.”
“Fiscal policy is raising costs for American families.”

Maggie's Farm - Saturday morning links

Why Johnny Can’t Read
Tis the Season for Jihadist Christmas Attacks
Zero Republican professors found across 27 academic departments at Yale

J.J. Sefton at Ace of Spades HQ - The Morning Report — 12/22/25

Leftists excuse perpetrators and vilify victims.
Leftism Promotes Psychological Abuse

Doug Ross - Larwyn’s Linx: The Fulton County 2020 Election Bombshell

• 5 Years Too Late, Fulton County Proves Trump’s Call To Raffensperger Right - Hans Mahncke
• Demons Despise the Sound of Shaking Paper - Chris Bray

Anonymous Conservative - News Briefs – 12/23/2025

National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) Contains Hidden Election Integrity Gem – Could Have Huge Implications for Voting Machines. Voting machines will have to undergo penetration testing by security experts before being approved for use.

I leave you with Sunday Funnies For 12-21-25 from Stately McDaniel Manor, Monday Memes …. from MaddMedic, Mondays..... picdump from Wirecutter, Monday Memes from Granite Grok, and Quick Hits Of Wisdom, Knowledge And Snark #3245 from 90 Miles from Tyranny.

Another Idiot Shooting At Someone In His Driveway

Why would you shoot at someone who was leaving? Homeowner charged for shooting at Amazon driver in Richmond County

According to the Richmond County Sheriff’s Office, the delivery driver knocked on Sidney Pittman’s door to deliver a package on Dec. 14 in Ellerbe. He told her it was the wrong address, but as she was driving away, detectives say the homeowner shot into her car with her 16-year-old son inside.

Ellerbe, North Carolina is about a 90 mile drive southwest of Raleigh, or about 75 mile drive east of Charlotte.

So now this genius homeowner is facing felony charges, and it will be hard to prove he had a reasonable fear of death or grave bodily injury, because she was leaving.

Your home is not a free fire zone.

Sadly he cannot be charged with felony stupidity in North Carolina.

So What Were You Doing at Age 11?

I'm guessing that stealing cars wasn't on the activity list, but that is just a guess. 'Somebody could have been killed’: Video shows kids leading Newburgh Heights police on stolen car chase before crash

“Shock. One word. Shock,” said Newburgh Heights Police Chief John Majoy.

This is the Police Activity video 11-year-old Leads Cops On Stolen Car Chase in Ohio

Police later determined the driver was an 11-year-old child, with two other children, ages 8 and 12, inside the vehicle. The pursuit continued westbound over the Denison Bridge, where the driver lost control after an abrupt turn and crashed into a nearby home.

That quote comes from the video description at YouTube. It also says the kids learned how to steal the car by watching YouTube videos.

The video is 7 minutes.

Together

While I am getting sick of the standard Christmas Carols, there are some not-so-standard songs that I still like.

This song is "Together" by Tarja from her 2017 album Spirits and Ghosts (Score for a Dark Christmas).

23 December 2025

The Horrible Movies of 2025

Despot of Antrim is a YouTube movie critic who shows up on some channels that I like. He is often a guest on Critical Drinker After Hours, which I quite like.

He considers the year 2025, and the 13 worst movies of the year. Big-budget, Hollywood movies. Of the 13 movies he mentions, 12 lost money, some lost a lot of money. And that is based on the numbers published by the studios. We know from history that the real budget numbers for Disney movies won't come out until Disney files tax forms with the UK government for films that were shot in the UK. We should see those final numbers in 2026.

It was a terrible year for the box office. Movie theaters can't survive on this kind of revenue, and if Hollywood keeps making slop, no one will see a reason to go to the cinema, and no one will have a reason to subscribe to streaming services.

This is the Despot of Antrim video The Worst Movies of 2025. It is a long video at just over 2 hours, but it is conveniently divided into chapters so you can watch what you want, and come back later if you're interested. I love this kind of thing, but then I love movies. I just wish Hollywood would make some worth seeing.

It Is Sad, That Things Have Fallen So Far

Holiday advice from Miguel Gonzalez: Out of Pocket

And please: Be careful driving and be extra careful wherever large crowds gather.

Carry and pack extra mags with the proper defensive ammunition.

Every Christmas gathering is a target.

Tuesday Links - 23 December

William Teach at Pirate's Cove has some news on the Climate Change front. NY Has Backed Off Of Climate Goals Or Something

Bummer. NY and Hochul just need to crack down, because the majority of New Yorkers voted to do this. They need to suck it up.

Chicago Contrarian - Downtown Alderman Moves to Strengthen CPD Curfew Powers

Alderman Brian Hopkins (2) has moved to give more power to the Chicago Police to deal with violent and dangerous teen takeovers of the city in the wake of the many crimes — including murder — that have occurred during these chaotic mob scenes which have wracked the city for years.

Doug Ross - 10 Steps to End Jihad Against the West - An Infographic

Call Islam what it is. Call dishonesty what it is. And call apologists for Islam what they are.

Aaron Hanscom at PJ Media - From Kristallnacht to Today: Why Jews Fear History Repeating

After the worst massacre against Jews since the Holocaust on Oct. 7, 2023, Jews throughout the world are becoming increasingly sensitive to signs that eerily parallel those preceding the Nazi genocide. Is this paranoia? An overreaction? Let’s look at a warning this week from a non-Jew, radio talk show host Hugh Hewitt.

Again from William Teach - Surprise: The Amount Of Fraud In Minnesota Is Vastly More

It’s funny when Democrats say “It’s only a billion dollars” like that is chump change in Reality Land

Wombat-socho - FMJRA 2.0: A Week In The Ruts.

Ceterum autem censeo Silicon Valley et Hamas delendam sunt.

The Other McCain - Thoughts From a ‘Heritage American’

Perhaps you’re not on X (formerly known as Twitter) and therefore have been spared the quarrel over “Heritage Americans.” Don’t know who coined that term or in what context it originated, but it seems to be a critique of the “proposition nation” ideology that George Will did so much to promote. Far be it from me to embrace or endorse a crypto-Nazi “blood and soil” ideology — the polar opposite of “proposition nation” — but the problem is that we are (or should be) talking about public policy.

Again from Wombat-socho - Rule 5 Sunday: In Honor Of Alice Cooper. (And there is a link to a song-of-the-day, but it might not jump out at you.)

The protagonist, Rally Vincent, was not only a hot babe who could shoot, but she could drive like a bat out of hell. What better gal to look for, if you need a girl with a gun and a job?

Pixy Misa at Ambient Irony - Daily News Stuff 21 December 2025: Door Out Of Summer Edition

Privacy is marketing. Anonymity is architecture. (Servury)

The value of your service provider not being able to recover your password is that they can't do anything else to your account either because they don't know who you are.

Alice Jones Webb on Women and Shooting

There was a time this line of questioning was fairly common. Maybe I've just become too reclusive in my old age. From Take It Outside: So You Want Your Girlfriend to Like Guns

This is an article by Alice Jones Webb from a few years back, that is no longer on the original website where it was published. She thought it would be worth rescuing it from oblivion.

For those of you who don't know, Alice Jones Webb has written for Outdoor Life, Field & Stream, Hook & Barrel, MeatEater, Free Range American, Recoil, and other outdoor publications. She describes herself as "a professional outdoor writer, solo hunter, muddy-boots homesteader, and unapologetic conservationist."

Do you love guns? Do you love your girlfriend? Do you wish your girlfriend loved guns?

Don’t despair. There are a few things you can do to turn your girl on to shooting.

While I’m not typically one to give relationship advice, I am one to regularly give shooting advice.

There are variations on some of the advice I used to give.

One is enroll her in a class. While men usually do love their wives and partners, they are not usually the best person to be teaching them about shooting. Too much baggage from the relationship. When I was teaching NRA classes we usually "discouraged" husbands and wives from sitting together for similar reasons.

Another is let her select her own firearm. A gun needs to fit your hand, the way your shoes fit your feet. A grip that is comfortable for you, might not be comfortable for her.

Here is probably the best piece of advice.

Make Her First Experience a Good One

If you want your girlfriend to love shooting, you need to do everything within your power to prevent a bad first experience. This is especially true if she’s never fired a weapon in her entire life.

Think about shooting with your girlfriend like your first date. If that first romantic encounter had gone south, you wouldn’t have had the opportunity for a second.

The same is true of shooting. You want to woo her with that first trigger pull. If it isn’t enjoyable, she probably won’t be making a second trip with you to the range.

When I was teaching people to shoot, I had access to a .22 short Beretta pistol. It was a small gun, but it was solid metal. The .22 short ammo resulted in virtually no recoil. For that first shot, or first magazine, it didn't really scare anyone too much or seem overwhelming. Usually the first trip to the range was some basic safety instruction, and fundamentals of shooting, but then it was mostly trying various caliber firearms to see what they were comfortable with, starting very small and working up. And since most indoor ranges today have some rental firearms, we could make sure that the grip issue was addressed.

I have seen too many women handed a .44 snubbie, either because someone thought it would be funny, or because they believe it is the best firearm ever manufactured. I routinely shoot a .357 Magnum revolver, but I don't enjoy shooting .44 special out of a short barrel, let alone .44 Magnum. Sometimes it is a brother/cousin looking for a laugh. Those guys are idiots, but the sisters know that. Sometimes not. The result is the same.

Don't be that guy, not even toward your sister.

So. Do you want the women in your life to be able to defend themselves, their children, and others? Do you want to occasionally take them to the range? Or do you want a quick laugh, and a long argument?

There is much more more. click thru.

Network Update Errors Can Cost Lives

When you are updating a firewall, mistakes can make it impossible for your systems to talk to the outside world. If you work at a telephone/telecom company, you can disrupt phone service for a lot of people. From The Register: Ten mistakes marred firewall upgrade at Australian telco, contributing to two deaths

As The Register reported at the time, Australia’s equivalent of the USA’s 911 and the UK’s 999 and 112 emergency contact number is 000 – Triple Zero – and local law requires all telcos to route emergency calls to that number. For 14 hours on September 18, Optus could not route some customers’ calls to 000 and was unaware of any problems on its network. The company eventually learned of the situation from customers who complained to its call center.

During the 14 hours of the outage, 455 calls to Triple Zero didn't go through. Two of the callers died.

Click thru for the details, and there are a lot of them. How the change was made without review. Why people noticed a problem but didn't escalate it. The fact that the call center never expected to be the front line on Triple Zero problems, and they didn't know what to do. And other issues.

Calling 911 in the US, 999 in the UK or 000 in Australia is a fine thing to do, but as we have seen all too often, it only takes a missed bit in a configuration update, or a guy with a backhoe, to make a huge hole in those services. You should figure out what your Plan B is. These are complex systems built, run, and maintained by flawed humans. They won't work perfectly all the time. Sometimes, they won't work at all.

I won't compare the internet, and the technology that we've built on top of it, to a house of cards, but it isn't far off. The recent, and what seem to be escalating, outages make that point for me.