Professor Yamane's writing is always interesting, even though I don't always agree with his positions on issues. We do agree on some things. Further Thoughts on The Ad Council's Gun Violence Prevention Campaign
Following up on my recent Substack about “Agreeing to Agree to Prevent Gun Violence,” I promised to post my complete responses to questions posed to me by the Washington Post Creative Group for their #AgreeToAgree collab with the Ad Council.
Those questions and responses are below. The #AgreeToAgree campaign quote attributed to me was crafted from these responses.
I started to write lengthy comments, but that quickly got out of hand... So here are some thoughts on one of his answers.
Question 5 of the survey:
5. What is the number one action we can all take to better protect children and teens from gun injuries?
We need to invest in the mental health of children and adolescents to reduce gun deaths.
His answer is longer than that, and you should read it, but he doesn't wander the way some authors do.
My thoughts: The entire society in 2025 is nihilistic. There is no Good and no Evil, which isn't too far off from there being no Right and no Wrong. I'm not talking about the inner city, because I have not lived in a major urban center in more than a decade (closer to 20 years). We have people shooting people knocking on their door asking for directions. People who turn into a driveway to turn around are shot from a distance. I'm not sure how you dig yourself out from that, where any interaction with a stranger is viewed as an attack.
In the case of our cites... Add in the economic devastation currently being visited on these cities, and I don't see that anyone in authority really wants to fix this problem.
Education is usually mentioned as a solution, but when you look at the percentage of students who can't read or do math at grade level in various districts around the country, it's clear that our current system of education is not working. It is not working, and the people in charge do not want to change a thing, except to give more money to the failing system. (Doing the same thing and expecting a different result is one definition of insanity.)
So how do you address the mental health of a society that has lost all hope?
When I think about the situation that one finds in our cities, (as I type this, Los Angeles is burning with riot-started fires) I am always reminded of Hobbes' "Leviathan." No cash bail, Criminal Justice Reform, and yes talk of concentrating on mental health. The result is that would-be bad guys are not afraid of getting caught. If they are caught, they will be released. And we have what Hobbes called "the time men live without a common power to keep them all in awe." Or, why do you think Justice holds a sword?
And we have everything that Hobbes said we would have under those conditions. Businesses flee the areas worst affected. There is no art, no invention, "and, which is worst of all, continual fear and danger of violent death, and the life of man solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short."
Oh, and I include the Logical fallacy image at the top because The Washington Post, the fish-wrap of a paper that started this, includes in the questioning a factual inaccuracy, which Professor Yamane pointed out, and they ignored.
2. What’s the number one thing you wish people understood about why gun injuries are the leading cause of death for children?
See my previous post for why that is a lie.